Circumventing region-locking to access Netflix may be illegal
Subscribe now for $100 (23 issues) and save more than 37% off the cover price!
Get the latest news from Computerworld delivered via email.
Sign up now
Using a VPN or a proxy service to access services like Netflix or Hulu from New Zealand may or may not be copyright infringement, according to an entertainment and a copyright lawyer.
David McLaughlin, whose firm McLaughlin Law represents a number of entertainment industry organisations including RIANZ, said there was no simple answer to questions about using VPNs to access region-locked content.
A VPN, or virtual private network, masks the IP address of a user and can make it appear as if they are accessing content from another country. VPNs are sometimes used to circumvent region-locking in order to use services that would otherwise be unavailable to New Zealanders, like video streaming service Netflix.
"What you’re really talking about here is more direct individual access to a service that they may or may not be allowed," McLaughlin said.
McLaughlin said the situation was complicated because the content being accessed was otherwise non-infringing, but it could be argued that the region-locking was a "technological protection mechanism", or TPM, which would be illegal to bypass.
"It comes down to whether it’s a technological protection measure and whether what someone is doing is actually circumventing it," he said.
"If someone can get around it, if it is a TPM, that would arguably fly pretty close to copyright infringement."
However information lawyer John Edwards said he did not believe region-locking was a TPM.
"I guess it’s arguable but I don’t think that there would be a very strong argument for that," he said. "That part of the copyright act I think is more aimed at mechanisms that are installed in the copyrighted materials or in the medium, like region-locking on DVD players."
Edwards also said even if using a VPN does break a technological protection mechanism, then it is outside New Zealand so not under the jurisdiction of the act.
Green MP Gareth Hughes, who opposed the recent Copyright (Infringing File Sharing) Amendment Bill in parliament, said he believed accessing these services was illegal for the same reason.
Read more at PC World here.
Posted by Anonymous at 16:21:40 on December 8, 2011
Posted by Anonymous at 8:41:34 on December 7, 2011
(1) If this is illegal, so would buying U.S. Apple gift cards from Ebay
(2) If buying region 1 DVDs from Amazon is allowed (which has a TPM), then why not allowing VPN access to a digital version of the file.
(3) Does that mean region free DVD players are now potentially banned? What about Open Source DVD software that bypass the region codes (e.g. VLC Player)
(4) We're allowed to Parallel import DVDs, isn't this just another form?
Posted by David at 21:45:09 on December 6, 2011
What sort of a statement is that? It's one or the other.
Posted by Anonymous at 10:12:30 on December 6, 2011
Posted by Ken Moon at 10:23:02 on December 6, 2011
End of story. Any DMCA/TPP or ACTA provisions around circumvention measures should be removed for just these reasons.
Posted by A Concered User at 16:24:55 on December 5, 2011
If I buy a DVD in the US I can watch it in NZ. Wait I can't because it has a region code. Had that problem when I moved here! Rights holders are methodically eroded the ability to actually own something. Where will this end? Oh that movie is digitally coded to my eyes only? Believe me they will find a way!
Posted by Anonymous at 16:43:28 on December 5, 2011
Is there something we need to know here?.....
Posted by Anonymous at 16:13:59 on December 5, 2011
Posted by Anonymous at 14:43:15 on December 5, 2011
Posted by @GrantisNZ at 12:55:53 on December 5, 2011