Labour promises online copyright reform

SUBSCRIBE
Newsletter & Subscriptions Computerworld is New Zealand's only specialised information systems fortnightly.
Subscribe now for $100 (23 issues) and save more than 37% off the cover price!
SIGN UP
Newsletter & Subscriptions
Get the latest news from Computerworld delivered via email.
Sign up now
‘Three stikes’ law comes into effect tomorrow
  • Share

The Labour party has put up a likely election-pleaser on the copyright front with promises to repeal the Copyright (Infringing File-Sharing) Act’s “internet termination” clause and to embark on a broader-ranging review of the Copyright Act if it is elected to government.

The controversial new law comes into effect tomorrow, September 1.

Opposition ICT spokesperson Clare Curran promises removal of the termination clause within 90 days of a Labour-led government being elected. The clause, which will allow a District Court to order the closing of a persistent copyright offender’s internet account for six months, is currently inactive, but can be brought into play with an Order in Council if the content-owning industry argues convincingly that existing penalties are not reducing illegal downloads.

The Labour party was widely criticised for having voted with the National-led government on a Bill text including the termination clause, despite having expressed its opposition to such a clause in debate on the Bill.

“Labour voted for the Bill in April because we stuck by a commitment to work with the government to enable internet service providers and rights holders to reach a compromise on copyright law,” Curran says.

A termination provision, however, is “unsustainable”, she now says.

“Labour remains committed to protecting the rights of the creators of works,” Curran adds. “This is a debate about shifting power, access to information, outdated business models and the immense potential of the internet to change our world. No parliament anywhere knows what to do about it yet, but Labour is committed to trying to find solutions.”

Such solutions are broader than changing one clause in the Act, she says. Labour’s review of the Act – promised to bring introduction of a Bill within 18 months – will be directed to “encouraging new business models to emerge which will distribute digital content easily and affordably.”

The copyright legislation policies will be released as part of Labour’s ICT and innovation policies in the next few weeks.
Comments
Huh Perhaps Clare has been issued a notice already??

"Oh my godzz, must repeal law!!!"
Posted by Anonymous at 7:23:36 on September 4, 2011

Flag abuse

Good law I actually support the legislation as is.

The argument that this law mainly protects foreign corporations conveniently ignores the fact that these industries (foreign owned or not) create large numbers of employment opportunities worldwide that need to be protected. When people think of the film industry they think of the millionaire actors, directors and producers. They (again) conveniently ignore the millions of other workers trying to earn a living as costume designers, boom operators, model makers etc.

These people deserve the same protection that you or I take for granted.
Posted by Anonymous at 13:12:06 on September 1, 2011

Flag abuse

Good law ?? MAFIIAA lackey noted.
Posted by Anonymous at 7:20:46 on September 4, 2011

Flag abuse

Protection Jobs should be created, not protected.

Jobs should not (and perhaps cannot) be protected. Many businesses are no longer able to employ the numbers of people they used to employ, this is just due to the progress of technology. Very few manufacturing jobs exist in New Zealand now, when there used to be many.
I agree that these people deserve the same protections as you or I. They do not deserve special protections just for them.
Posted by Daniel at 21:58:03 on September 2, 2011

Flag abuse

riiight Does Labour forget that they were the ones who originally wrote the law? And their version was far harsher and far more costly for ISPs than the one now implemented by National?
Posted by Spiro at 12:53:04 on September 1, 2011

Flag abuse

Intelectual Property Law is a joke.Already being bypassed by serious users.
Posted by robbie at 9:01:01 on September 1, 2011

Flag abuse

nick@tangerineworks.com I think we need to go further than this.

We need to examine

a) whether "Intellectual Property" actually offers society any benefits whatsoever... regardless of the fact that its enforcement has become impossible, and attempts to set up structures for doing so create dangerous intrusions into our privacy.

b) why exactly are our politicians working for the interests of (usually foreign) corporations, rather than their electorates? What must we do to prevent this?

c) how we can avoid situations like the one we saw, where people who were clearly incompetent to do so, were responsible for passing laws over things they don't understand. (rushed through, as "emergency" legislation)

d) a formal investigation into the American Govt's attempt to pay our govt to inflict this law on us - What is the process by which this corruption happens?, What other overtures have been made? What must we do to make sure that we are never in a situation again where foreign govts get to try to secretly bribe our elected representatives.


Posted by Nick Taylor at 15:45:27 on August 31, 2011

Flag abuse

nick@tangerineworks.com 100% agree with above, especially d). Do we really want US dictating our legislation (again) ?

"A February 2008 cable notes that Consumer Affairs Minister Judith Tizard and Trade Minister Phil Goff were presented with a list of shortfalls to submit as the legislation was being drafted."

http://tvnz.co.nz/technology-news/us-lobbied-nz-over-copyright-laws-wikileaks-cables-4149178
Posted by Anonymous at 9:17:16 on September 1, 2011

Flag abuse

election promise...?..really......? ...dosnt that imply that you think you actually have some sort of chance on actually getting elected into govt this year....?

PLEASE ! Your polling 25%..? Its not trending up....?

http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/5535823/Greens-shoot-up-in-poll

Make sure you are high on the list Clare !




Posted by Anonymous at 14:52:43 on August 31, 2011

Flag abuse

Yeah Right! Thanks Labour for proposing and passing the stupid law in the first place. They must think the public has the memory of a goldfish.
A reminder here ->
http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/1755057/Internet-copyright-law-delayed
Posted by Anonymous at 11:27:41 on August 31, 2011

Flag abuse

computerworld
Computerworld NZ has now reached LinkedIn! Join to expand your networks and meet others interested in information systems.