Updated: Stephen Fry calls NZ broadband a 'digital embarassment'

SUBSCRIBE
Newsletter & Subscriptions Computerworld is New Zealand's only specialised information systems fortnightly.
Subscribe now for $100 (23 issues) and save more than 37% off the cover price!
SIGN UP
Newsletter & Subscriptions
Get the latest news from Computerworld delivered via email.
Sign up now
British actor and technology fan says New Zealand needs to stand up for its broadband. Update 4:55 pm - Telecom responds
  • Share

British actor Stephen Fry has sparked criticism of New Zealand's broadband this morning, after he called it a "digital embarassment" on Twitter.


Fry, who is in Wellington to film The Hobbit, complained to his four million followers on Twitter about having his internet throttled back by Telecom while uploading images and videos of his stay in New Zealand.

He implored New Zealanders to stand up to demand better internet service.


He compared it to similar tactics by Comcast, an American ISP, by saying "Comcast style throttling is a for the economy it's disastrous [sic], for visitors for everyone. It won't stop illegal bit torrentinf. Makes as much sense as closing a lane of traffic because there's congestion."

This created much discussion on the state of New Zealand's broadband infrastructure and services, with many complaining that it has taken a foreign celebrity to highlight some of the issues.

Last month, a paper published by the Commerce Commission assessing the demand side of the Ultra Fast Broadband network concluded that data caps did not appear to be of great concern to those questioned by the commission: “Surveys undertaken for the high speed broadband services demand side study indicated that most consumers and SMEs are satisfied with their data caps.”

Fry's comments come at the same time the Commerce Commission is holding a conference on the Future of Broadband in Auckland, with many on Twitter taking the opportunity to link the two using the #FutureBB hashtag.

At the time of writing this article, Telecom has not responded to a request for comment. However Telecom has approached Fry on Twitter with an offer to provide him a T-stick (3G USB modem).

Update at 4:55 pm

Telecom has responded to Computerworld's request for comment, saying the incident started from a misunderstanding around data plans.

A spokesperson for Telecom says Fry is staying at a residence in Wellington, and was using a Telecom customer's data capped plan when he went over the customer's allowance. Telecom says the customer had chosen to have their broadband internet throttled instead of being charged extra for over cap data.

Since then, Telecom has upgraded the customer's account to a higher data cap, which now includes over cap data charges.

Telecom would not reveal the details of this plan, but say the account holder is paying for it fully. The spokesperson says Telecom was working with the customer, and not doing 'any special favours' because of Fry's comments.




Today's tweets by Stephen Fry criticising New Zealand broadband


Comments
NZ Broadband British actor Stephen Fry has sparked criticism of New Zealand's broadband
Posted by Jenita at 17:38:20 on February 24, 2012

Flag abuse

Data Caps are your choice Data Caps are not on all plans. If you are on a capped plan it's because YOU choose it. If you don't want to be capped or throttled change plans and pay the extra. Simple!
Posted by Anonymous at 15:03:14 on February 22, 2012

Flag abuse

Slingshot! Please lets stop wasting bandwidth on this. Do what I did vote with your money. Slingshot offer $60/month uncapped. Go check it out and stop moaning about data caps, in NZ not all ISPs have them!

Note: I'm nothing to do with slingshot other than being a very happy customer!
Posted by Anonymous at 14:46:35 on February 21, 2012

Flag abuse

Telecom data caps. Stephen needs to understand the basic problem. Years ago a Labour government (who are now against selling country assets) sold off Telecom as a monopoly to the Americans. Since then they have been ripping off Kiwis while sending huge profits back to American shareholders, and not investing anything into upgrading the network. Why should they, when there is no competition.
The issue of the data caps is because there is only ONE line into the country and thus its usage must be limited, otherwise there would be those who wouldn't be able to access the Net and pay Telecom's fees for its usage. It makes business sense - for Telcom.
Posted by Peter C. at 13:47:16 on February 21, 2012

Flag abuse

UK Broadband UK broadband is better? I doubt it. Friends tell me its much worse than here, with slower speeds, and service no better.
Posted by Dave at 13:36:04 on February 21, 2012

Flag abuse

NZ vs UK broadband I understand where Stephen is coming from... I'm originally from the UK and my hometown was dug up in the early 1990's and fibre laid - so NZ is about 20 years behind in that regards. Internet access is a luxury item in NZ.
Posted by Anonymous at 13:05:03 on February 21, 2012

Flag abuse

NZ vs UK broadband 20 years behind?? What a load of rubbish. I lived in London for 4 years and found it was slower than here. You need to get facts straight mate. The UK is far from technologically advanced - they just recently put pin numbers on their eftpos cards (20+ years later), before then you were expected to sign a piece of carbon paper.
Posted by Anonymous at 18:57:58 on February 21, 2012

Flag abuse

NZ vs UK broadband Coming from the UK also, bear in mind that the infrastructure is very different here. The economy is very different and always will be different, which is why money can be spent more easily on fibre. So what if NZ is 20 years behind? You cant compare. Get over it or go home.
Posted by Anonymous at 13:39:52 on February 21, 2012

Flag abuse

NZ vs UK broadband Thought someone would say that! I'm well over it thanks!
Posted by Anonymous at 13:49:03 on February 21, 2012

Flag abuse

NZ vs UK broadband Thank god the UK is better in every respect than NZ. I wonder why UK people come here. We have more trash, higher prices for everything and much slower broadband. Why do you live here?
Posted by kiwi at 13:20:55 on February 21, 2012

Flag abuse

computerworld
Computerworld NZ has now reached LinkedIn! Join to expand your networks and meet others interested in information systems.